Accessibility/Mobile Features
Skip Navigation
Editorial News
Classified Sites

Brandon Sun - ONLINE EDITION

Diversion endangers Lake Manitoba's future

Whenever the Portage Diversion is opened, tonnes of phosphorus are dumped into Lake Manitoba.

RUTH BONNEVILLE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILES Enlarge Image

Whenever the Portage Diversion is opened, tonnes of phosphorus are dumped into Lake Manitoba.

Two floods in the last four years have been devastating for the farmers, ranchers, First Nations, cottagers, and permanent residents around Lake Manitoba. The floods have also wrought ecological disaster. A brown ribbon of death now surrounds the water's edge where floodwaters destroyed the lakeside forest. And now we are killing the lake itself.

If we continue to routinely divert a major river system -- the Assiniboine -- from one watershed to another and continue to overload a lake ripe for eutrophication with phosphorus, we risk turning Lake Manitoba into the world's largest bowl of toxic blue-green Jell-O.

Lake Manitoba is the world's 33rd-largest freshwater lake. It is exceedingly shallow with an average depth of just 4.5 metres. It is effectively the world's largest pond. Like most ponds, it warms quickly in summer and is biologically productive. It is now too productive.

Eutrophication occurs when a lake is overloaded with nutrients, especially phosphorus and nitrogen. In freshwater lakes, the key limiting nutrient is usually phosphorus. The most obvious results are blooms of blue-green algae (actually cyanobacteria). The spectacular blooms on Lake Winnipeg, ones that can be seen from space, earned it the dubious title of the most threatened lake in the world.

Phosphorus is oxygen to the fire of eutrophication: Cut off its supply and you stop the blooms. In Lake Manitoba, phosphorus is usually the nutrient in short supply. Except when the Portage Diversion is open.

Every time the diversion is opened, tons of phosphorus are dumped into a lake that does not need it. The diversion becomes the primary phosphorus source for the lake. The phosphorus that is carried in Assiniboine waters arises from various sources. Some is natural, some is from towns and cities upstream, some is from agricultural runoff. Phosphorus loading into Lake Manitoba is now a problem. A big problem.

In the summer of 2013, a fish kill spanned the lake, from Lundar on the east to Langruth on the west. Dead fish of all species and sizes littered the lakeshore. The most likely explanation was oxygen depletion associated with algal growth. This fish kill was deeply worrisome, potentially a leading indicator of more severe problems ahead.

Two recent reviews show phosphorus loading rises with the use of the Portage Diversion and report levels of biological productivity that have risen into the danger zone on Lake Manitoba.

In 2003, the Lake Manitoba Regulation Review provided the following clear recommendation to the minister of conservation: "The use of the Portage Diversion should be restricted to those periods of time and flows which are absolutely necessary to protect downstream interests along the Assiniboine River and in Winnipeg. The operating rules of the Portage Diversion should be re-examined, with the objective of asserting its primary function as a short-term flood-protection work, and to minimizing its discharge of nutrients, sediments, debris and other materials into Lake Manitoba."

This recommendation was echoed by the province's own scientists from Conservation and Water Stewardship in presenting to the Lake Manitoba Lake St. Martin Regulation Review after the 2011 flood. The conclusion was the Portage Diversion needed to be used less to protect water quality.

There is an obvious reason why.

Measurement of chlorophyll-a is used by water-quality scientists as an index of algal growth, a shorthand measure of eutrophication. In the 2013 review, it was reported that chlorophyll-a levels in Lake Manitoba were within the reported historical range. Nothing to worry about.

However, what was missed was the large blue-green elephant in the room tapping them on shoulder.

Chlorophyll-a levels were reported back to 1992. To use a term familiar to quantitative ecologists, a clear and significant time trend exists in the data.

Over the last two decades, as the Portage Diversion has been used more and more, chlorophyll-a levels have more than doubled. Average levels now rival those seen on Lake Winnipeg. And Lake Winnipeg has the highest chlorophyll-a levels of any large lake in the world, a big reason why it has been aptly described as the "sickest lake in the world."

Lake Manitoba has joined Lake Winnipeg in intensive care.

The 2003 review, and also the later 2013 review, recommended the Portage Diversion be used less for a variety of reasons including water-quality concerns. The response of the current provincial government, the recipient of both reviews? Use it more.

In 2013, flows on the lower Assiniboine were artificially restricted to just over 8,000 cfs with any surplus sent to Lake Manitoba in the Portage Diversion. Much more water was sent to Lake Manitoba than necessary. In 2014, the policy was to artificially restrict flows to 10,500 cfs. That was until all hell broke loose in late June.

This water-management policy drips with irony.

In early June, the province announced with great fanfare a progressive water-management strategy to restore the health of a very sick Lake Winnipeg by addressing the problem of eutrophication. That was excellent news.

But while Manitoba Conservation was rescuing Lake Winnipeg, one lake over, Manitoba Infrastructure and Transport was doing exactly the opposite. They were using the Portage Diversion and wrecking water quality on Lake Manitoba.

An ecological crisis has arrived on Lake Manitoba with this policy dissonance. Now it is not just one lake we need to rescue, but two.

 

Scott Forbes is an ecologist and professor of biology at the University of Winnipeg and has owned property on Lake Manitoba for 15 years.


This is the first of two columns by Forbes on the future of Lake Manitoba. The second will be published Tuesday.

History

Updated on Monday, July 28, 2014 at 7:50 AM CDT:
Replaces photo

  • Rate this Rate This Star Icon
  • This article is currently rated an average of 4 out of 5 (1 votes).
  • We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high. If you thought it was well written, do the same. If it doesn’t meet your standards, mark it accordingly.

    You can also register and/or login to the site and join the conversation by leaving a comment.

    Rate it yourself by rolling over the stars and clicking when you reach your desired rating. We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high.

Sort by: Newest to Oldest | Oldest to Newest | Most Popular 2 Commentscomment icon

You can comment on most stories on brandonsun.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.

These are the figures for phosphorus loading into Lake Manitoba reported in 2009.Source: The Portage Diversion and its impact on Lake Manitoba's Water Quality, by Reanne Pernerowski.Wpg Free Press, 5 May, 2011….."Diversion unhealthy for Lake Manitoba." by Bartley Kives.From the Portage Diversion: 16,543 tons (93 per cent) From the Waterhen River: 779 tons (four per cent.) From the Whitemud River: 561 tons (three per cent)
The province sure knows the best way to pollute a body of water.

Lake Manitoba will eventually, in the not too distant future, become another very sick algae polluted water source, much the same as Lake Winnipeg.

Post Your Commentcomment icon

Comment
  • You have characters left

The Brandon Sun does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. Comments are moderated before publication. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.

letters

Make text: Larger | Smaller

Brandon Sun Business Directory
The First World War at 100
Why Not Minot?
Welcome to Winnipeg

Social Media