Accessibility/Mobile Features
Skip Navigation
Skip to Content
Editorial News
Opinion
Classified Sites

Brandon Sun - PRINT EDITION

Israel's elaborate civil defences save hundreds of lives

Between July 8 and Aug. 4, Gaza militants fired more than 3,350 rockets at Israel. Despite that barrage, Israel reported only three dead and 82 wounded civilians. Some observers therefore dismissed the fire as mere “bottle rockets” that did not justify Israel’s heavy counterattacks. But the rockets were lethal enough; together they carried some 53 tons of explosives. The low toll was actually due to Israel’s defensive efforts.

Israel’s bomb shelters and warning systems form part of its defence. They rarely make the news, but since 2005 the country has spent half a billion dollars preparing its civil defences. This reduces the casualties that occur if rockets strike.

Bus stop shelters in southern Israel are built from concrete, rather than glass. Many homes have a reinforced room where the family can hide. Loudspeaker and cellphone alerts give residents a few seconds to sprint for cover.

Research suggests these measures prevent most potential casualties. One study estimates fatalities would be at least three times higher without these expensive preparations.

Israel’s Iron Dome missile defence systems provide a more visible line of defence. They claimed to have shot down 83 per cent of urban-bound rockets last month. That implies the casualties could otherwise have been another six times higher.

Those interceptions were pricey. Israel is now spending $225 million to resupply its batteries, or about $389,000 for each of the 578 rockets intercepted. That is in addition to the technology’s billion-dollar development cost, and the half-billion spent to build the 10 batteries.

There is also some skepticism about those interceptions. Some analysts think the success rate was much lower than claimed. The interceptor missiles clearly were exploding in the sky. But if the blasts didn’t disable a warhead, it could still blow up its target.

Israel also avoided casualties by pre-emptively destroying rockets on the ground in Gaza. Aircraft and artillery attacked 1,100 in the first phase of Operation Protective Edge. The ground assault eliminated another 1,900, including ones hidden underground or in United Nations’ schools.

If those 3,000 rockets had been launched, they could have increased Israel’s civilian casualties by 89 per cent.

But those pre-emptions were tragically costly. Israel’s military spending for the operation approached $2 billion. Army casualties were high, Palestinian casualties were higher and Gaza was devastated.

The rockets admittedly were weak in one sense. Compared to the previous 2012 conflict, their accuracy was lower. Only 21 per cent of them headed towards Israeli towns this time, versus 32 per cent in 2012. Otherwise, Israel’s casualties would have been 54 per cent higher still.

The accuracy might have decreased because the militants fired their unguided rockets at longer ranges this time. They threatened more towns, but hit them less often.

The threat was enough to harm Israel’s economy. The estimated loss due to fewer tourists, closed businesses, etc., is $1.3 billion. That’s about $387,000 per rocket fired.

Now let’s combine all these factors. (We’ll conservatively assume that the Iron Dome only had a 41 per cent interception rate, half the apparent figure.) What if Israel had prepared no civil defences, no interception system, no pre-emptive strikes and faced fire as accurate as in 2012?

Multiplication shows Israel’s civilian casualties would have been about 15 times higher. That means about 1,275 dead or wounded instead of 85 — hardly “bottle rocket” results. The total would have approached the 1,531 casualties actually inflicted by Hezbollah’s rocket attacks from Lebanon in 2006.

The best means of preventing rocket casualties is a lasting diplomatic agreement. But that has been elusive so far. Attaining peace in the Middle East is not rocket science — it’s much more complex than that.

» Michael J. Armstrong is an associate professor at Brock University. He has been the Fulbright visiting research chair in war and peace studies at Norwich University, and a visiting professor at the U.S. Naval Postgraduate School. This column appeared in the Winnipeg Free Press.

Republished from the Brandon Sun print edition August 23, 2014

  • Rate this Rate This Star Icon
  • This article has not yet been rated.
  • We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high. If you thought it was well written, do the same. If it doesn’t meet your standards, mark it accordingly.

    You can also register and/or login to the site and join the conversation by leaving a comment.

    Rate it yourself by rolling over the stars and clicking when you reach your desired rating. We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high.

Sort by: Newest to Oldest | Oldest to Newest | Most Popular 1 Commentscomment icon

You can comment on most stories on brandonsun.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.

This is good news if you are pro-Israel but would be bad news if you were pro-Hamas or anti-Israel. Some Canadians would see effective Israeli bomb shelters as but another example of how Israel has an "unfair" advantage over Hamas. I would not be one of them.

Post Your Commentcomment icon

Comment
  • You have characters left

The Brandon Sun does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. Comments are moderated before publication. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.

Between July 8 and Aug. 4, Gaza militants fired more than 3,350 rockets at Israel. Despite that barrage, Israel reported only three dead and 82 wounded civilians. Some observers therefore dismissed the fire as mere “bottle rockets” that did not justify Israel’s heavy counterattacks. But the rockets were lethal enough; together they carried some 53 tons of explosives. The low toll was actually due to Israel’s defensive efforts.

Israel’s bomb shelters and warning systems form part of its defence. They rarely make the news, but since 2005 the country has spent half a billion dollars preparing its civil defences. This reduces the casualties that occur if rockets strike.

Please subscribe to view full article.

Already subscribed? Login to view full article.

Not yet a subscriber? Click here to sign up

Between July 8 and Aug. 4, Gaza militants fired more than 3,350 rockets at Israel. Despite that barrage, Israel reported only three dead and 82 wounded civilians. Some observers therefore dismissed the fire as mere “bottle rockets” that did not justify Israel’s heavy counterattacks. But the rockets were lethal enough; together they carried some 53 tons of explosives. The low toll was actually due to Israel’s defensive efforts.

Israel’s bomb shelters and warning systems form part of its defence. They rarely make the news, but since 2005 the country has spent half a billion dollars preparing its civil defences. This reduces the casualties that occur if rockets strike.

Subscription required to view full article.

A subscription to the Brandon Sun Newspaper is required to view this article. Please update your user information if you are already a newspaper subscriber.

letters

Make text: Larger | Smaller

Election 2014
Brandon Sun Business Directory
The First World War at 100
Why Not Minot?
Welcome to Winnipeg

Social Media