Proposal seeks ban on LGBTQ+ books

Advertisement

Advertise with us

A delegation that appeared before the Brandon School Division on Monday is calling for certain books that feature LGBTQ+ content to be banned from school libraries.

Read this article for free:


By clicking the button above, an account will be created and you will begin to receive some of our recommended newsletters. You may opt out of any newsletter by visiting your Email and Communication Preferences page or by clicking "unsubscribe" at the bottom of any email.

or

Already have an account? Log in here »

We need your support!
Local journalism needs your support!

As we navigate through unprecedented times, our journalists are working harder than ever to bring you the latest local updates to keep you safe and informed.

Now, more than ever, we need your support.

Starting at $15.99 plus taxes every four weeks you can access your Brandon Sun online and full access to all content as it appears on our website.

Subscribe Now

or call circulation directly at (204) 727-0527.

Your pledge helps to ensure we provide the news that matters most to your community!

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Brandon Sun access to your Free Press subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on brandonsun.com
  • Read the Brandon Sun E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
Start now

*Your next Free Press subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $20.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 11/05/2023 (1286 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

A delegation that appeared before the Brandon School Division on Monday is calling for certain books that feature LGBTQ+ content to be banned from school libraries.

At Monday’s meeting, Lorraine Hackenschmidt, who identified herself as a grandmother of children in the division and a former school trustee, advocated for the creation of a committee that would review books discussing gender identity and sexual health issues and potentially remove them from shelves.

She linked the discussion of books with transgender themes to the sexual grooming of youth and pedophilia, a common argument against queer content.

The Brandon School Division administration office. (File)

The Brandon School Division administration office. (File)

After the presentation, trustees Breeanna Sieklicki and Calistus Ekenna applauded Hackenschmidt for the presentation. Sieklicki implored attendees to support Hackenschmidt at the next scheduled meeting on May 23, when the board will discuss the proposal at greater length.

On Tuesday, Brandon Pride denounced the presentation in a statement posted on its social-media platforms. The organization called for local allies to reach out to BSD trustees with their opposition and encouraged them to attend the next meeting.

Reached by phone Tuesday, school board chair Linda Ross declined to comment ahead of the May 23 meeting. The gallery of the BSD’s boardroom was filled to capacity for the meeting, with trustees remarking that there hadn’t been that many visitors in a long time.

Hackenschmidt introduced herself as not being a doctor, lawyer or psychologist, but a concerned person who has “done research on the subject of the LGBTQ ideology, the type of books in our school libraries on this subject and the effect that they might have on our children and grandchildren.”

At the meeting, she quoted a 2019 press release from the Canadian Centre for Child Protection calling for the creation of a new framework to spur action toward the removal of online photos depicting the sexual abuse of children.

Though the release is specifically about images of children being sexually assaulted or abused, which Hackenschmidt acknowledged, she then asked about the impact of content featuring gender identity discussions.

“Where are they getting the idea that they are in the wrong body?” Hackenschmidt asked. “This is a dangerous path our children are being enticed to go down.”

She claimed that 80 per cent of children experiencing gender dysphoria grow out of it by late adolescence and that since human brains don’t finish maturing under a person’s mid-20s, material discussing gender identity should be removed so children aren’t convinced to make permanent changes to their bodies. No source was given for the figure cited.

She also quoted Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban’s views on LGBTQ+ issues. While in power, Orban’s party has banned the depiction of homosexuality or gender reassignment in media targeted to those 18 and younger.

Reference was made to a story by an outlet called World Daily News from May 2 about 22 countries at a recent United Nations annual commission on population and development rejecting a push by U.S. President Joe Biden for expanded LGBTQ+ education.

While the Sun could verify that the commission took place last month, it could not find any stories of countries rebuking Biden for trying to push for that kind of education or any information about the news outlet referenced.

Hackenschmidt provided an example of a book she believes is harmful — “Being Jazz,” written by a transgender girl, Jazz Jennings, in which she discusses the mental health struggles that have accompanied her transition. Though Jennings identifies as a woman and uses she/her pronouns, Hackenschmidt exclusively referenced the author as “him” during her presentation.

Other books Hackenschmidt claimed were harmful include books with information about masturbation, Toni Morrison’s 1970 novel “The Bluest Eye” — which discusses incest — and Katie Rain Hill’s 2014 memoir about gender transition, “Rethinking Normal.”

The Sun was unable to reach Hackenschmidt or Sieklicki for comment.

In its statement, Brandon Pride drew a link between Hackenschmidt’s presentation and efforts in the United States to introduce anti-transgender legislation and stated it represents an attempt to censor art.

“The crude and false impression presented last night that books containing queer and transgender content are promoting pedophilia or a harmful agenda is sad, frustrating and very alarming,” the statement says.

“Much of the language used during this presentation is the same hateful rhetoric that we have been hearing recently from the USA in states that are passing laws to limit and ban gender-affirming care and how drag artists can perform. When a group of people in your community doesn’t understand how important it is to have representation in media, especially for youth, it is both disheartening, disappointing and scary.”

In a phone interview, Brandon Pride chairperson Alyssa Wowchuk said Brandon isn’t the only community seeing this kind of push.

Earlier this month, the Winnipeg Free Press reported on an effort to have several books that discuss gender, sexuality and consent banned from the South Central Regional Library, which operates branches in Miami, Manitou, Altona, Morden and Winkler. Calls have also been made to defund that library network over the matter.

In some American states, legislation was recently passed preventing transgender children from receiving gender-affirming care and from playing on sports teams that match their gender identity.

Last month, Montana’s House of Representatives banned transgender Rep. Zooey Zephyr from its chamber for the rest of its legislative session after she told colleagues they would have blood on their hands if they continued to pursue anti-transgender legislation.

According to Wowchuk, Brandon Pride has received messages of support from people in communities and school divisions where similar censorship attempts have been made.

“Pride is for everyone,” she said. “Right now, we need our allies, we need our community and it’s situations like these that show why we still have Pride to begin with.”

She said the effect of withholding information on these topics and preventing queer children from seeing themselves represented in media can lead to depression or suicide.

Last year, the Canadian Medical Association Journal released a report stating that transgender and non-heterosexual adolescents were five times more likely to experience suicidal thoughts than their cisgender and heterosexual peers.

“That’s why it’s so much more devastating when someone twists that message and that positive celebration of identity into something so grossly misrepresented and crude and honestly, disgusting,” Wowchuk said.

The head of Brandon and Area PFLAG, Laura Crookshanks, also expressed concern about Monday’s presentation. That organization works to support and educate local members of the LGBTQ+ communities and their families.

“I’m very concerned any time you try to link sexual identity or gender orientation with something like pedophilia,” Crookshanks said.

“I think that’s very detrimental to kids and young people in the school division who may be questioning or in the process of coming out and it puts them at great risk for their own mental health.”

Should the school division follow through with Hackenschmidt’s request, Crookshanks said it would send the message that queer students don’t matter and there is something wrong with them.

Local defence lawyer and parent of three Andrew Synyshyn said he plans on attending the next school board meeting to support opponents of the presentation.

He said that while Hackenschmidt’s presentation was veiled under a concern for explicit content being shown to children, it was clear to him that she was really arguing against things that don’t align with her system of beliefs.

Though he doesn’t dispute her right to hold her beliefs, he said it’s not appropriate for the Brandon School Division — which states in its policies that children are entitled to learn in an encouraging setting regardless of sex, gender or sexual orientation — to even entertain what was presented Monday.

“For that trustee member to encourage them and say they had courage to say things that were hateful and bigoted is alarming,” Synyshyn said in a phone interview.

Another concern for him is that Hackenschmidt didn’t propose criteria for which content would be considered acceptable, essentially asserting that private citizens — not professionals — would get to decide the content people are allowed to consume.

“I wonder what her response would be if I suggested that antiquated books teaching about mystical beings in the sky who demand sacrifice and set out laws about who can marry who and what kind of fabrics can be blended together aren’t appropriate for children either,” he said.

“If you don’t get the reference, I’m talking about the Bible. I guarantee you the response would be ‘well, that’s not the same thing.’”

» cslark@brandonsun.com

» Twitter: @ColinSlark

Report Error Submit a Tip

Local

LOAD LOCAL ARTICLES