Brandon Sanatorium named in lawsuit filed on behalf of ‘Indian hospital’ patients


Advertise with us

A class-action lawsuit on behalf of former “Indian hospital” patients has named the “Brandon Indian Hospital” as one of the 29 segregated hospitals targeted.

Read this article for free:


Already have an account? Log in here »

We need your support!
Local journalism needs your support!

As we navigate through unprecedented times, our journalists are working harder than ever to bring you the latest local updates to keep you safe and informed.

Now, more than ever, we need your support.

Starting at $4.99/month you can access your Brandon Sun online and full access to all content as it appears on our website.

Subscribe Now

or call circulation directly at (204) 727-0527.

Your pledge helps to ensure we provide the news that matters most to your community!

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 03/02/2018 (1659 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

A class-action lawsuit on behalf of former “Indian hospital” patients has named the “Brandon Indian Hospital” as one of the 29 segregated hospitals targeted.

This hospital is more commonly known as the Brandon Sanatorium, which served Indigenous tuberculosis patients from 1947 to 1958.

At the time of its closure, patients were shipped out to the Ninette Sanatorium and the Brandon location was restructured as the Assiniboine Hospital.

Tyler Clarke/The Brandon Sun) Sharon Dixon is seen with her mother, Alice Marina Young, in the common room of Valleyview Long Term Care Home in September. In the 1950s, Young was an eight-year resident of the Brandon Sanatorium, a facility that has been cited in a $1.1-billion class-action lawsuit on behalf of patients.

According to a CBC News story, the $1.1-billion class-action lawsuit cites allegations of widespread mistreatment and abuse among so-called “Indian hospitals,” where patients were forcibly detained.

Brandon woman Alice Marina Young spent approximately eight years at the Brandon Sanatorium in the 1950s, during which she said that she was shut off from her family and society at large.

She escaped on at least one occasion, only to be captured by a police officer and returned to the hospital.

Submitted The 250-bed Brandon Sanatorium is pictured at some point during its 1947-59 run.

Now an 83-year-old resident of the Valleyview Long Term Care Home in Brandon, her time at the Brandon Sanatorium remains cemented in her mind.

During a conversation with The Brandon Sun in September, she asked on several occasions whether she was at the Brandon Sanatorium.

Daughter Sharon Dixon said this week that although her mother has never said anything about being mistreated, she believes that the class-action lawsuit is worthwhile.

University of Winnipeg historian Mary Jane McCallum has been studying Manitoba’s racially segregated tuberculosis treatment facilities with postdoctoral fellow Scott de Groot for the past few years, collecting the oral histories of those involved.

While certain cases of abuse might not have been overt, McCallum said she has found a parallel between how the Brandon Sanatorium operated and how the residential school system was structured.

Located at the corner of 10th Street and Queens Avenue, the Brandon Sanatorium had a “social orientation” program that helped assimilate patients into white communities.

McCallum and de Groot conducted and processed six substantial interviews with patients of Manitoba sanatoriums.

“All of the interviewees spoke about their experiences of being removed from their families and the hardships they faced — both short and long-term — as a result,” McCallum wrote. “These consequences included a loss of language — which resulted in difficulties adjusting back to family and community life after their return from the hospitals.”

These past patients also complained about the extreme isolation they faced at sanatoriums, as well as the length of time they were made to remain in the health-care facilities.

Manitoba Lung Association CEO Neil Johnston said that what he has heard from past patients of these sanatoriums has been “certainly very troubling and tragic and something that we’re concerned about.”

The Manitoba Lung Association was founded in 1975 as a division of the Sanatorium Board of Manitoba to tackle community health programs and education services.

The Sanatorium Board of Manitoba’s only activity at present is its operation of the Manitoba Lung Association, and Johnston said that they’ve long since divested of medical records that individual sanatoriums would have kept.

Uncertain as to the local implications of the national class-action lawsuit, Johnston said that they’re currently trying to figure out things themselves.

“Because we’re basically starting from scratch ourselves, from a record perspective, we have to be careful and make sure we get the information we need to take any kind of steps,” he said.

Although the Ninette Sanatorium is not listed in this class-action lawsuit, Winnipeg-based Indigenous advocate Gerald McIvor is working on developing a wider-reaching class-action lawsuit, which he said on Friday would be national in scope and field in federal court.

This class-action lawsuit would centre on “a serious breach of human rights and Canada’s fiduciary responsibility toward First Nations people,” he said.

Unlike the Brandon Sanatorium, the Ninette Sanatorium was not dedicated exclusively to Indigenous people.

The class-action lawsuit that cites the “Brandon Indian Hospital” (Brandon Sanatorium) was filed in Toronto last week by Koskie Minsky LLP and Masuch Albert LLP of Alberta.


» Twitter: @TylerClarkeMB

Report Error Submit a Tip


Advertise With Us