Judge not, lest ye be judged?

Advertisement

Advertise with us

You know the common theme with any scandal?

Read this article for free:


By clicking the button above, an account will be created and you will begin to receive some of our recommended newsletters. You may opt out of any newsletter by visiting your Email and Communication Preferences page or by clicking "unsubscribe" at the bottom of any email.

or

Already have an account? Log in here »

We need your support!
Local journalism needs your support!

As we navigate through unprecedented times, our journalists are working harder than ever to bring you the latest local updates to keep you safe and informed.

Now, more than ever, we need your support.

Starting at $15.99 plus taxes every four weeks you can access your Brandon Sun online and full access to all content as it appears on our website.

Subscribe Now

or call circulation directly at (204) 727-0527.

Your pledge helps to ensure we provide the news that matters most to your community!

To continue reading, please subscribe:

Add Brandon Sun access to your Free Press subscription for only an additional

$1 for the first 4 weeks*

  • Enjoy unlimited reading on brandonsun.com
  • Read the Brandon Sun E-Edition, our digital replica newspaper
Start now

*Your next Free Press subscription payment will increase by $1.00 and you will be charged $20.95 plus GST for four weeks. After four weeks, your payment will increase to $24.95 plus GST every four weeks.

Opinion

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 04/09/2010 (5917 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

You know the common theme with any scandal?

* One or more lives will be ruined and careers destroyed.

* There will be a whistleblower who is either a cad or a hero, but that will take some time to figure out.

Bruce Bumstead/Brandon Sun
Now that's a lot of birds! While the Sun was on a tour of the new McKenzie Towers project in the old McKenzie Seeds building in downtown Brandon on Thursday, photographer Bruce Bumstead had the chance to get some rare views from one of the city's highest vantage points. And while there were some spectacular views, there was also this Hitchcockian view of a flock of pigeons enjoying the late summer sun on some rooftops near Ninth Street and Rosser Avenue. While a roosting pair of falcons on the McKenzie building keep some of the birds at bay, I believe the city still has far too many of these flying rats for our own good. At least we don't have any outdoor sculptures to be defiled by the cooing creatures.
Bruce Bumstead/Brandon Sun Now that's a lot of birds! While the Sun was on a tour of the new McKenzie Towers project in the old McKenzie Seeds building in downtown Brandon on Thursday, photographer Bruce Bumstead had the chance to get some rare views from one of the city's highest vantage points. And while there were some spectacular views, there was also this Hitchcockian view of a flock of pigeons enjoying the late summer sun on some rooftops near Ninth Street and Rosser Avenue. While a roosting pair of falcons on the McKenzie building keep some of the birds at bay, I believe the city still has far too many of these flying rats for our own good. At least we don't have any outdoor sculptures to be defiled by the cooing creatures.

* TV ratings will soar. Newspaper readership will spike.

And with all but the greatest of scandals — those involving Michael Jackson and Tiger Woods come to mind — the sands of time will eventually blanket over what today occupies our thoughts, coffee shops and chat rooms.

And there will be someone else to throw to the lions.

But that’s then — right now there’s a super scandal happening in Winnipeg that is making news across Canada.

Here’s the story in a nutshell, condensed from articles produced by our sister paper the Winnipeg Free Press, and others, including the National Post and CBC News (which broke the story):

Lori Douglas, Associate Chief Justice of the Manitoba Court of Queen’s Bench Family Division, is at the centre of a scandal after it came to light she once had at least 30 sexually explicit photos posted online.

Her husband uploaded the photos of her in bondage gear engaging in oral sex onto an Internet porn site, that caters to a specific racial fetish.

Her husband, Winnipeg family lawyer Jack King, then approached one of his clients to have sex with his wife. There is no evidence Douglas knew what King was doing.

The hubby’s client, Winnipeg computer programmer Alex Chapman, 44, told CBC he first met King in 2002 when he hired the lawyer to represent him during his divorce proceedings.

Chapman, who is black and originally from Trinidad, claimed that King encouraged him to visit a certain porn website that depicts sex between black men and white women.

Using a provided password, Chapman found the nude sex pictures of King’s wife, who was a lawyer at the time, under the name "White Princess."

It’s said King was suffering from depression at the time.

After his divorce was finalized in 2003, Chapman filed a complaint with King’s law firm, Thompson Dorfman Sweatman. Soon after, King took a one-year medical leave.

By now granting media interviews about his relationship with the couple, King’s lawyer says Chapman has breached the 2003 confidentiality agreement he signed with King in exchange for $25,000.

The Canadian Judicial Council received a complaint from Chapman on July 15. The Manitoba Law Society is also investigating a complaint by Chapman.

Douglas has requested to be temporarily relieved of her duties as a sitting judge and will remain in her position in an administrative capacity.

Chapman this week filed three separate lawsuits at the Winnipeg courts, seeking $10 million from King, $7 million from Douglas and $50 million from the law firm Thompson Dorfman Sweatman where the couple worked.

See what I mean? This is the type of amazing made-for-TV-movie story that simply has to be told.

It’s kind of like the perfect storm for itchy tabloid headline writers just wanting to give someone a good scratch. The Winnipeg Sun gave the judge some particularly special attention on its Wednesday front with the screaming nod to Henny Youngman, Take My Wife, Please.

Now some folks this week on various open-line radio shows and online have derided the media for simply doing a first-class smear job on the poor judge.

Sorry, this is definitely newsworthy. And since much of the story has already been proven — the pictures apparently do still exist on a disc and there was legally documented hush-money paid to shut Chapman up — this is not simply a piece of gossip that has gotten out of control.

It’s a delicious dish that should be savoured by all consumers of good news.

As for the judge, she’s toast. Done. Like dinner.

It doesn’t matter what happens with the complaints currently before the various professional bodies and what happens with the lawsuits.

She’ll be known as the "White Princess" for some time to come.

And as this story will have legs because there’s also a question as to how much information on the issue she knew and what she gave to officials during the detailed selection and vetting process for her to become a judge, and then to be promoted to associate chief justice.

It’s nice to think what you do in your personal life behind closed doors is nobody else’s business, but once it’s revealed, it’s public domain.

And while a pop star or sports figure can be excused at times for some, er — eccentricities — a judge has to rise above the rabble and be squeaky clean.

A jurist also has to be especially careful who he or she associates with — and who they marry.

Especially a senior family court lawyer who must, on a daily basis, make judgment on other people’s relationships.

 

A classic tabloid front page
A classic tabloid front page

MANITOBA’S POWER 30?

 

The Winnipeg Free Press has again managed to produce a list of folks deemed most powerful in the province without looking much beyond the Perimeter Highway.

Of the 30 people on the list, published one week ago, only five have any connections to rural Manitoba. And none of them are from Brandon or Westman.

And what has become an annual regional shunning is what prompted me a few years ago to create my own version of the Freep’s power list — except they had to be from the Sun’s coverage area, which is all of Westman and a little into the Parkland and Central Plains regions.

I’ve had fun with my list — which I extended to the Top-50 — and have already been asked when I plan to create this year’s offering.

Well, given that it’s a general municipal and school board election year, I’m going to wait until after the ballots are counted on Oct. 27 to see where some mayors, reeves, councillors and trustees get slotted.

So it’ll be a little later than usual, likely early November.

 

TYPICAL TYPO IRONY

 

So I wrote a column last week headlined Glamorizing Grammar where I looked at some public typos and poor use of the language on signs and such.

And sure enough, there was a typo in my copy — this after an eagle-eyed editor caught my original mistake and corrected it. After some checking, it seems some computer Gremlin in our system decided to run the uncorrected version of the page.

The gaffe? I used the word "new" instead of "knew."

And thanks to the dozen or so readers — including my publisher, Ewan Pow — who quickly let me know about the error once they saw the printed paper.

 

ON WOUNDED KNEE

 

On July 24, I stumbled a bit while walking in the shadows backstage at the Brandon Folk, Music and Art Festival. Didn’t fall down, didn’t feel any pain. Didn’t miss a beat.

The next day my right knee started to hurt.

Within two days I could barely walk and was in excruciating pain at my doctor’s office.

The initial diagnosis was that I had likely broken or ripped something in the joint. Went for X-rays. Got some painkillers.

The next day I bought the first cane of my life and find myself needing to use it on more days than I’d like.

By the end of the week I was getting the first cortisone shot of my life (I’ve had several since).

And I was told I would need an MRI to determine what exactly was wrong with my knee before a decision on surgery will be made.

That could mean a bit of a wait.

In the meantime, I’ll just hobble around in varying degrees of pain and discomfort and be the butt of cane jokes.

Apparently there is a lot of depth and enjoyment to cane humour. And when I yell at the neighbourhood kids to "Get off my lawn!" I now have a cane to shake at them.

Report Error Submit a Tip

Columns

LOAD COLUMNS ARTICLES